That the Tackler position be changed to the Tackling Midfielder who would score as follows: 3 x tackles + Disposals/2 – 2xFA. This change would occur for the PSD of 2019.
Download full spreadsheet of Review of New positions here
EXTRACTOR
Extractor v Midfielder
Findings:
10 of the Top 20 Extractors are not in the Top 20 Midfielders
6 of the Elite Extractors are not Elite Midfielders
Conclusion: As expected, the Extractor position rewards a specialised midfielder for their Clearance work in a way that is not generally rewarded in pure Midfield stats
HALF-FORWARD
Half-Forward v Forward
Findings:
16 of the top 20 HF’s are not in the top 20 Forwards
Conclusion: The HF position is a unique position that rewards half forward flankers and a small number of dominant centre half forwards
RUCKMEN UTES
Ruckmen Utes
Findings:
6 of the top 20 utilities were ruckmen of which 4 were elites. However despite scoring highly ruckmen utes are less valuable than similar scoring non-ruck utes because:
They are one dimensional without being multitalented in other positions so unlike non-ruck utes, do not improve team depth
They are injury prone
They rarely dominate year after year, evidenced by above
Conclusion:
This is roughly in line with expectation, though slightly more than expected likely due to increased hit outs in 2017.
However given above issues they do not appear to be too dominant and have increased the pool of available quality utes as expected.
HALF-BACKS
Half backs v Forwards
Findings:
Only 4 of the top 20 HB’s were top 20 in any other position
Hurley and Hibberd were named as All Australians showing the true value of this HFFL position
As predicted when introduced, the Half-backs are identiical in scores and standard deviation to the forwards (comparing players ranked 2 to 20) – low scoring position with high standard deviation. Like forwards, this makes recruitment of a top player valuable since the scores drop off quickly but not too valuable because overall scores are still low
Conclusion
In line with the prediction, the Half-backs are a unique position, rewarding previously unrecognised players.
Half-backs are identical to forwards in scoring and standard deviation and recruiting decisions should be based on this
We’ve had our first season with the new positions and it has been an absolute cracker. One of the most exciting ends of the regular season with such a tight battle for finals spots echoing a stunning AFL season.
The GF was the one we needed to see. The 2 best teams this season had their finals rematch, their 4th encounter of the season to finally settle the discussion